The National’s sixth album, High Violet, is an extremely soothing listen, despite misleading track titles such as Sorrow, Terrible Love, I’m Afraid of Everyone, Little Faith or Anyone’s Ghost.
Conversation 16 is the personal thoughts of a man who is struggling with a marriage to a woman he loves. It is probably the most meaningful song on the album because it confesses what all spouses fear of one another.
He is a mundane middle-aged man who is bored with his life. He says exactly what he’s supposed to, and only tells his wife he is miserable after she’s gone to sleep.
In the lyrics we begin to feel his guilt so much that we carry it with him, and while we want to find comforting words for him, or ourselves, they seem completely absent. Between the title of the song and Matt Berninger’s droning voice, we feel as hopeless as he.
With the most honest of lyrics, he sings, “I am evil,” and professes to his wife that “You’re the only thing I ever want anymore,” or “I do not want to disappoint anymore.”
In a nation whose divorce rate outweighs faith in one another, this song has the ability to connect with an audience and shake it to truth.
The song is a perfect motif for the rest of the album: unfeigned lyrics that, though sometimes morbid, are unbelievably refreshing.